You’re sending marketing emails, watching your open rates, maybe even A/B testing subject lines. Good. That means you already have the building blocks in place.

The next step is giving those efforts a direction. When your open rates, list growth, and click-throughs are tied to a specific goal, they stop being just metrics and start telling the story of how email is growing your business.

That’s what this article is about: setting email marketing goals that connect to revenue, so every metric you already track has a clear job to do.

Why do email marketing goals matter?

Because without goals, you’re just sending emails and hoping for the best.

It’s a bit like throwing darts blindfolded: you might hit something, but you won’t know what or why. An email newsletter goes out on Tuesday because Tuesday is “email day.” A promo drops when sales are slow. A welcome email exists because someone said you need one. None of it is wrong, but none of it ties back to a specific outcome you’re trying to achieve.

And this isn’t just a marketing thing; it’s a human thing. 

Think about it: there’s a reason vision boards went viral, fitness apps make you set a target weight, and every productivity guru out there goes on and on about writing things down. 

When you know exactly what you’re aiming for, your brain starts working differently. You stop reacting to whatever feels urgent and start asking one simple question: is this getting me closer? Same with email. 

A 22% email open rate on its own? Just a number on a dashboard. But if your goal is 20 new bookings this month and that 22% only brought in 2 — now you know the problem isn’t visibility, it’s what happens after the open.

How to set email marketing goals that drive revenue

Setting email goals isn’t complicated, but it does require you to think about your business first and your email marketing metrics second. The SMART framework (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time-bound) is a solid structure for this and the four steps below put it into practice.

Identify what your business needs right now

A freelance designer notices they get plenty of website visitors but very few inquiries. What their business needs isn’t more traffic. It’s converting the audience they already have. So their email goal becomes about turning subscribers into booked clients, not growing the email list.

Before you touch your email dashboard, ask yourself: where am I losing potential customers right now? That’s the goal your emails should be working toward.

Connect each goal to a revenue outcome

A freelance photographer wants to improve their open rates. But when they ask themselves ‘what do more opens actually do for my business?’ they realize the real goal isn’t opens — it’s getting more people to click through to their booking page. The open rate matters, but only as a step toward filling their calendar. Every metric you track should be able to finish the sentence: “this matters because it leads to ___.”

Match your email strategy to your business stage

Not every goal makes sense at every stage. Before you set one, ask: does this match where my business actually is right now, or where I think it should be?

A new online shop with 300 subscribers shouldn’t be worrying about reactivation campaigns; there’s barely anyone to reactivate. Their priority is getting those 300 people to make a first purchase. Meanwhile, an established yoga studio with 3,000 contacts might focus on improving their click-to-purchase rate, since they already have the audience — they just need more of them to act.

Focus on 1–2 goals per quarter

A small agency decides to chase list growth, open rates, click-through rates, and conversions all at once. Three months later, every metric moved a little but nothing moved enough to matter. Next quarter, they pick one goal: get 15 new client inquiries from email by June. Everything they send serves that single target.

Fewer goals, more progress. Pick one or two that tie directly to what your business needs this quarter, give them a number and a deadline, and let everything else wait its turn.

Six email marketing goals worth setting 

Now that you have a framework for setting goals that tie back to your business, let’s get into the specific ones worth your attention. For each goal, we’ll cover why it matters for revenue, what realistic email marketing benchmarks look like, and what to try when things aren’t moving.

#1. Grow your email list

The more engaged subscribers you have, the more people see your offers: no ad budget required. But don’t let the number fool you. If you have 400 subscribers who open your emails and click through to your services page, you’ll generate more bookings than someone with 4,000 contacts who haven’t opened an email since last summer.

Why it pays off	Every engaged subscriber is a potential buyer you reach at zero ad cost
Realistic benchmark	250–500 engaged subscribers is a strong starting base; once there, a 2–3% monthly growth rate is a healthy, sustainable pace
Where to start	Move sign-up forms where people actually see them, offer something specific in return, promote beyond your website

If you’re looking for a platform that makes list building painless, SiteGround Email Marketing plugs straight into WordPress and the SiteGround Website Builder, so every sign-up on your site becomes a subscriber in your list automatically. No manual imports, no extra tools, no losing leads between steps.

#2. Improve open rates

That 22% open rate from earlier? It told you something was off. Now let’s talk about fixing it, because if people aren’t opening your emails, nothing you do inside them matters. Even a modest jump from 22% to 28% meaningfully changes how many people see your offer and reach your call to action.

Note: Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection marks emails as “opened” the moment they’re delivered to an Apple Mail inbox, regardless of whether the subscriber actually looked at them. That’s why the widely cited 40–43% industry average is misleading — a chunk of those opens never really happened. A more useful approach is to compare your own campaigns against each other rather than chasing a benchmark that includes phantom opens.

Why it pays off	More opens = more people seeing your offer = more clicks and sales
Realistic benchmark	20–35% for small businesses; track the 3-month trend, not individual sends
Where to start	Write specific email subject lines (“3 spots left for our April workshop” > “March Newsletter”), test send times, check deliverability if rates drop suddenly

#3. Increase click-through rates

Clicks are the closest thing to buying intent that happens inside an email. Someone who clicks is actively moving toward spending money with you: landing on a product page, a booking form, or a sign-up page.

Why it pays off	More clicks = more people on pages where they can buy, book, or sign up
Realistic benchmark	CTR: 2–3%; CTOR (clicks from openers): 5–7%
Where to start	One email, one primary CTA; match content to subject line promise; ditch vague links like “Learn More”

#4. Convert subscribers into buyers

This is where every other goal on this list either pays off or doesn’t. You grow your list, improve opens, get more clicks; all so that eventually, someone buys. That moment when a subscriber becomes a customer is the most direct line to revenue in email marketing. And it adds up: email marketing consistently delivers one of the highest ROIs of any marketing channel. But that only happens when your emails are actually built to convert, not just to inform.

Why it pays off	The most direct connection to revenue: a subscriber spends money
Realistic benchmark	1–5% conversion rate depending on industry. But if your list is under 1,000, percentages aren’t very useful, so track the actual number of sales or bookings each campaign brings in instead.
Where to start	Check what happens after someone clicks: slow-loading pages, confusing checkout, or pricing that wasn’t mentioned in the email will lose them. For new subscribers, send a few helpful emails before asking for the sale.

Automation helps here. With SiteGround Email Marketing , you can set up a welcome sequence that sends 2–3 helpful emails before any sales pitch. Once it’s built, it runs on its own.

#5. Re-engage inactive subscribers

Inactive subscribers don’t just sit there; they hurt you. Email providers track engagement, and if too many people ignore you, your emails start landing in spam for everyone, including the subscribers who actually buy from you.

A quick gut check: open your email platform’s analytics and see how many contacts consistently don’t open or click. Most platforms (including SiteGround Email Marketing) show this data at campaign level.

Why it pays off	Re-engaged subscribers = buyers recovered at zero cost; removed subscribers protect email deliverability for paying customers
Realistic benchmark	At least 50% of your list should be active (opened/clicked) within the last 90 days
Where to start	Review your analytics page metrics: if the same contacts never open or click, try a different approach: a discount, exclusive content, or a reminder of why they signed up. No response after 2–3 attempts? Remove them.

#6. Clean your list to protect deliverability

It’s not the most exciting goal on this list, but it might be the most important. Dead addresses, ghost subscribers, and inactive contacts who haven’t engaged in months all drag down your sender reputation, which means your campaigns start hitting spam for your best customers too. Cleaner list, better results.

Why it pays off	Clean list = better inbox placement = more people see your campaigns = more revenue from the same sends
Realistic benchmark	Email bounce rate under 2%, unsubscribe rate under 0.5%, spam complaints under 0.1%, deliverability above 95%
Where to start	Quarterly cleanups; remove hard bounces immediately, soft bounces after 2–3 campaigns, inactive contacts after re-engagement attempts

Quick note: SiteGround Email Marketing automatically removes hard bounces (emails sent to addresses that no longer exist or were never valid). For soft bounces (temporary failures, like a full inbox or a server that’s temporarily down), check your campaign analytics regularly. If the same addresses keep soft bouncing across several campaigns, remove them. Same goes for inactive contacts: if someone hasn’t opened or clicked anything in months, it’s worth cleaning them out manually to keep your list healthy.

Email marketing goals that sound smart but go nowhere

Not every goal that sounds productive actually is. Here are a few that small business owners set all the time and why they tend to lead nowhere.

• “I want to grow my list to 10,000 subscribers.” 

We’ve already talked about why list size alone doesn’t mean much, but it’s worth repeating because it’s one of the most common goals small business owners set. Big round numbers feel motivating, but 10,000 subscribers who don’t open your emails won’t generate more revenue than 500 who do. The goal shouldn’t be a number on your list. It should be what that list is doing for your business.

• “I want to hit the industry average open rate.” 

Industry benchmarks are based on data from millions of senders of all sizes, industries, and list qualities. A 42% average includes enterprise brands with dedicated email teams and seven-figure budgets. Comparing your 800-person list to that number will either make you feel like you’re failing when you’re not, or give you a false sense of success when there’s work to do.

• “I want to improve open rates, click rates, conversions, list growth, and deliverability this quarter.” 

That’s not an email marketing strategy, that’s a wish list. When you track five things at once, you spread your attention so thin that nothing moves meaningfully. Three months later, every metric shifted a little and none of them shifted enough to matter.

• “I saw [big brand] does this, so we should too.” 

We keep coming back to this for a reason. Context matters. A re-engagement email flow that works for a retailer with 200,000 subscribers and a full marketing team doesn’t translate to a freelancer with 600 contacts and two hours a week for email. Someone else’s winning strategy can easily become your time sink if it doesn’t match your resources, list size, and business stage.

Start your email marketing journey with a goal that pays

You didn’t start your business to babysit an email dashboard. So don’t. Pick one goal, give it a number, give it a deadline, and send emails that serve it. That’s the whole strategy. And if you need a platform that keeps things just as simple, SiteGround Email Marketing gives you the sign-up forms, automation, segmentation, and analytics to set a goal and actually track whether you’re hitting it. No complexity for the sake of complexity.

Improve Your Email Campaigns with SiteGround!

Want your emails to reach more people? Try SiteGround Email Marketing. With an average delivery rate of 98.8%, your emails will land in your subscribers' inboxes.

START NOW

Frequently asked questions about email goals